I listen to TONS of Actual Play RPG's (Glass Cannon Podcast, Sneak Attack!, TAZ, Friends at the Table, Campaign, etc)...in the D&D, Pathfinder, Edge of Empire, L5R systems. And also listen to tons of Audio-Dramas (Wolf 359, We're Alive, Magnus Archives, Bright Sessions, Archive 81, Our Fair City, Sayer, Tumanbay, etc.). And just want to share that Rusty Quill Gaming Podcast is an absolute BEST OF THE BEST...totally awesome in every way for both actual-play RPG's / audio-drama realm.
This quintet of personalities is absolutely infectious. They have fantastic Grade A+ rapport, are clearly all great friends, and IMO find the perfect balance in tone: great blend of seriousness + 100% in character and amazing roleplay, and equally laugh out loud (like, belly laughs) hilariously funny. Even the Character Creation episode before the show itself gets rolling is brilliant and makes you fall in love with their personalities. The GM treats the Pathfinder rules with respect, but also values storytelling, improvisation and character interaction over battle mechanics. Think of it as a fusion of the tone of Glass Cannon + the freedom of Campaign from Star Wars.
This is such an underrated podcast and needs more iTunes reviews and support, please take a listen!!! Should be considered one of the best Actual-Plays ever made!!!