I listened to all 5 episodes in Season 1, which should tell you that it was good enough to hold my interest for that long. However, the show could be a lot better. The premise is based on the old Kolchak: The Night Stalker show, except instead of a reporter for a fictional wire service in Chicago, the protagonist is a blogger in Albany. There is even a Mrs. Vincenzo referenced many times, but she is his landlady rather than his editor. One can only hope she will be memorable as Simon Oakland was if she becomes an actual speaking part.
I like the fact that rather than try to do a monster of the week for every episode, it basically did the entire 1st season devoted to one story arc. The story itself was fairly creative, and the production values were solid.
The voice acting was largely well done, with a few glaring exceptions (a story read by a character in the second episode really stands out as all time bad). The intro spiel runs a little on the long side, when listening to these episodes back to back it can become tedious, although that's what fast forward is for, I guess. While the lead character's narration is professionally done, there is something about either the delivery or the writing that makes it seem as if he is way more impressed with himself than the listener would find him to be. Tough for anyone to live up to the incomparable Darren McGavin, but I found it off-putting at times.
I'll definitely download Season 2 when it starts, and if you like this genre, I'd recommend giving it a try. Your mileage may vary from mine.