Radio Rental

Reviews For Radio Rental

This is the best podcast of all time. Please never stop and please make more episodes. One a day, forever preferably. Thank you.
like why should anyone pay that much for such little time. are you paying the storytellers well?
I work in distribution, so I listen to podcasts all day!! I’ve been listening to this whole stream in like 3 work days!!! Obsessed!!!
Snap judgement with teeth
Season one is definitely the best!

5/5

Yea, binged this one real quick. Really well done. 🥰

5/5

By Batgirl
Put this one right up there with ATWWD but make it 20Xs creepier!! This is definitely a new road trip favorite- 20/10!
Love love Radio Rental!! The stories are ones you won’t hear anywhere else. Hosts are amazing. Truly creepy stuff. The latest season has been a little disappointing with lack of new episodes and didn’t enjoy the stories as much as previous seasons, so hopefully that changes with the upcoming. Also, please add more stories per season and more exclusive content for those that pay :)
If you’re on your way to work or falling asleep.. these are PERFECTION.
I make narrative podcasts for a living. This one is well produced, with one notable flaw: the company’s owner, Payne Lindsey, inserting himself into each episode to summarize a bunch of stuff we’ve already heard. This adds nothing to the story and, in fact, takes a lot away. It breaks the spell and takes you right out of the story. The only point seems to be to include Payne.
Best quality true crime that doesn’t last a long time or take forever to get to the point. I wish they would drop more frequently!!!! Omg they need to hurry !
This would be a five star review but for one thing: Payne, stop chiming in out of nowhere with your own thoughts on the person’s story. It adds nothing and completely wrecks the atmosphere that has been built up to that point. It hasn’t annoyed me to point of no longer listening yet, but we’re close to that. Rainn Wilson is brilliant as always, and most of the stories are great. There’s a few duds here and there, but they’re few and far between. This podcast made my rainy weekend indoors very entertaining. UPDATE: I saw there was a new episode, but it behind a paywall? Unsubscribed.
I binged this show so fast, I was looking for a new podcast and someone recommended this one. It is so good!! I even listen to the adds haha because Terry kills me!
This is my second rating for this podcast. The first season was mind blowing- so good. It’s gotten weaker since then and I understand there are only so many stories out there. Now you want us to subscribe to Tenderfoot for a weekly 16 min show. It’s not worth it RR. Terry Carnation and Malikai (sp) I still love you. Please do better? Rhonda
We have to pay to subscribe now?!?
The production is what you have come to expect from this team! Awesome, different story telling.
Such a cool take on the different experiences people can remember! The stories are short and all told so differently! Love it so far!!!
Absolutely loving it! Binge listened all the existing episodes in 2 days. Can’t wait to hear more spooky stories, and love Terry of course.
I love the way this show is done! The sound effects from back in my day. Only disappointment, the show is short. Wish it could hit the hour threshold. The show is written extremely well!!! Highly recommend!!
Another podcast that I thoroughly enjoy but you need a subscription to listen to! It didn’t start off like this and I don’t understand why podcasters keep doing it! Some of us have turned to podcasts bc they’re free and we can’t afford to pay to listen to them. Now they all seem like cash grabs to me! I miss you Terry Carnation. I’m sorry but I’m unfollowing bc what’s the point if I have to pay to listen. Y’all acting like you don’t have enough money… It was great while it lasted but I just can’t afford to pay to listen. Go back to being free (as podcasts should be) and maybe you’ll get more listeners. 🤷🏻‍♀️
Wow these stories are so intense! Love the mix of supernatural and these crazy close calls! Keep it up! Terry man, don’t ever change! KateM
I love this podcast so much! The stories are chilling and creepy, Terri Carnation is hilarious and the video store aspect resonates with me so much since I grew up in video stores. My family owned a video store for a long time so I think the video store theme is awesome! Can’t wait to hear more!!
SEriously LOVE the stories and comedy and just EVERYTHING. PERFECTION!!
This is hands down my favorite podcast. It’s spooky but not horrifying, scary but not so bad that I can’t listen to it alone in my house. My ONLY complaint is the long hiatuses with no updates. I unsubscribed to tenderfoot because of the random 5 month stretches with no new shows. Super excited for the next season, please make more!!

5/5

Hands down this is one of my favorite podcasts. I always wish there were more episodes! Love it!
A slay of a spooky podcast love that it’s true stories 🕺🏼💃🏼🕺🏼
Last couple of seasons can barely be classified as horror. The newest story about the writing on the mirror with condensation is just silly. If you don’t actually clean the mirror it stays there’s for a long time. She even mentions this in the story.
FYI : Maliki …unfortunately set fire to the radio rental store, no injuries. Don’t hold your breath in anticipation for an October 2022 release. Thanks for the bummer Mordecai . … stupid cat..
Some of these stories have scared me so bad that I convinced myself that the house I was cleaning was haunted, to the point that I called the owner and asked if they have ever experienced paranormal activity. They haven’t, but turns out the toilet screams when you flush it, so……
This is one of the smartest, most chilling things I’ve ever listened to. Every story scares the crap out of me. But it’s so sparse, and I don’t really want to pay to get a new episode every now and then. Otherwise love it.
The stories themselves are fantastic. Super unnerving and often creepy enough to make me stop what I’m doing because I’m at the edge of my seat. I’ve been given goosebumps a handful of times listening to people recall close encounters and weird phenomena ’re good enough that I will probably re-listen to my favorites after I’favorites after I’m finished with the entire available episode selection. The music and sound design accompanying each story is excellent, too. Really well-produced. But this isn’t a great podcast. It’s obvious many like the Rainn Wilson character he’s playing, and that’s great that he’s hitting the mark for others, but I personally find it insufferable and unneeded. None of it is funny or worth listening to. Absolutely nothing is added to this show with his performance aside from a longer runtime. During the first several episodes, it actually sounded like he didn’t even want to be doing this character. I now skip th’s easy to tell when they’re Thankfully, the stories have a different sound to them than whatever theater he’s doing, so it’sound to them than whatever theater he’s attempting, so it’s easy to find the beginning of each one. And Payne used to do this thing in early episodes where the storyteller would recount a part of their story and then Payne would interrupt to literally summarize what the storyteller just said. It was truly annoying and unneeded, much like the Rainn Wilson character segments. Thankfully, he’s gone entirely in later episodes and just lets the storytellers do the heavy lifting. If only they would do the same for the host. Overall, I recommend this show to those who are interested in weird and creepy stories, but it’s not a great podcast.
Add more episodes!
I’ve loved this show but It’s almost Halloween so I expected a ton of new episodes this month! Im a subscriber so I guess I’ll cancel? v disappointed
This is by far my favorite podcast of all time, but new episodes are NEVER released (and as a subscriber, I’m completely underwhelmed… how much am I paying a month?). If new episodes do come out, listeners maybe get two or three, then it’s another 6 months before yet another teaser. I’m unsubscribing and subscribing to Spooked instead— incredible ghostly podcast! I’ll miss you RR, but that’s not new.

5/5

Anything Rain touches is gold!
Can’t wait to listen to these stories every chance I get. Only thing is ……….. They haven’t put new stories out. When will they put new stories out. Thought it was once a week. Still love this podcast. I even have my notifications on to alert when new stories come out.
The retro, spooky podcast thats almost like a hauted blockbuster radio show. But it’s real.
Can’t put my phone down ! Love the fact that u never know what creepy story your gonna get next! And Terry ( who I thought was weird at first) adds a nice little chuckle in between the stories! Wich u will need to pull u out of the gripping ness a lot of these stories have!I promise u will come to love him just like I have!
The stories in this past season aren’t as interesting as the first couple were. I used to love this podcast, but the last season was a disappointment
I’ve listened and relistened, the storytellers are so captivating

5/5

By cgweare
more, please!
Finally something different and creative! TC is such an awesome character! I am obsessed! Thank you!

5/5

By art.366
I’m a practicing witch of 3 years. It takes a lot to scare me. This podcast scares me. The paranormal stories especially get to me because they remind me that while we can banish bad vibes, entities can still really mess with your wellbeing. Stay safe y’all don’t forget to cleanse ur house!!
I don’t even know how to describe this podcast. One of a kind. Creepy stories told by the people it happened to and then you have the VJ/DJ Terry Carnation who changed the stories/vcr tapes? A mischievous cat named Malachi. Eerie stories with a bit of comedy relief in between and of course Payne Lindsey. Anything with Payne is amazing.
I’ve listened to an upwards of 50 podcasts and this one is my favorite. A must listen!
The most captivating podcast I’ve heard in years. Awesome job!
Omg I love this show! Highly recommend listening especially if you’re into mysteries and thriller. I also love Terry Carnation. He’s amazing.
Seriously one of the best podcast I’ve heard.