First, the positive: Comic News Insider has been around for years and established itself both in the fan and professional community. Jimmy often reviews a mixture of both mainstream and below the radar books, as well as random geek culture tv shows, movies, etc. I wouldn't know about the McNuggetini if not for him!
Though best with an equally funny and engaging co-host (and there's been a carousel of co-hosts lately; some good, some not-so-much), Jimmy is a good host.
Unfortunately, the show has been suffering a lot lately (months) from audio-related issues. First, an easy fix: Please stop sipping/"Ahh"-ing into the mic. Also, the music cues sound like someone is playing them off a phone or voice-recorder into a microphone, they're very tinny. When using a laptop microphone, it picks up the room's ambience, sometimes a good thing (ie, "We're at San Diego Con and podcasting from our hotel room!"), and sometimes bad ("Someone's knocking on my apartment door, be right back."). I think the real microphones sound better.
Lastly, the intro's outdated, since Joe Gonzalez hasn't been a regular co-host for the MONTHS that I've been listening.
Jimmy has promised to be updating and fixing some of these issues, and I look forward to it being a 4-star show once again!