I listen to both episodes every week, this show is part of my regular routine! Love relevant, love their takes on faith and pop culture, and they have a great range of interesting and “relevant” guests and do well interviewing them. I’m almost always left with a mix of entertained, challenged and inspired, with each of those varying in levels each episode.
My only true critique is that their journalism about news issues is not consistently accurate, especially when reporting on events/accusations from more than a couple of years ago. Most times, probably 19/20, it’s pretty solid reporting. But unfortunately there have been a few instances where I heard something that I knew of before and remembered it differently, and then found very credible (and secular, and not right-wing) news outlets that had reported on those older stories in a way that “debunks” the false accusation presented by Relevant, in the podcast and online. It’s a bummer when that happens, it’s not always the case but it does happen often enough to warrant fact-checking bigger news items I hear on this podcast.
I’ve heard this podcast drag in particular a very credible Christian organization through the mud with inaccurate reporting, one that does so much good for literally millions in need around the world. In that specific instance, it took literally 3 minutes of a google search to find multiple credible news sources had debunked that rumor, including the original source of the false report!! (I sent those sources to relevant, no response from them, which was disappointing after subscribing for the print on and off for a decade). I was mortified by the story, because I knew for multiple reasons that the accusations were not true, including from personal experience and then from confirming through researching the news stories. (To show how poor the journalism was, simply looking at a map debunked the story, let alone the other details presented by other news outlets). I don’t think they realize how that type of inaccurate reporting can really hurt those who the false reporting is about, and can influence their listeners.
Again, I love Relevant! I appreciate their transparency, not being fake-happy-Christians but really reflecting genuine Christianity. I’m thankful for their fearlessness to speak up about social justice and our political-party-less-Jesus. I’m thankful for their willingness to talk about uncomfortable news about spiritual leaders that fall and help listeners process the range of feelings that news causes. And I’m thankful for their voice and their efforts to continue to be heard and inspire those who hear.