I'm a lover of Gilmore Girls and heard about this podcast through the guys over at Bald Move from their Mad Men Happy Hour cast. At the recommendation of A. Ron, I couldn't wait to dive into Return to Stars Hollow. I've listened to every podcast released. The hosts leave too much to be desired. Hyper critical of the show, the writing, and fashion in some areas, and surface-level analysis in other areas, Celeste and Cordia are uneven hosts at best. When I say surface-level, I should start a count of how many times they can describe a scene as "funny" or "good." I don't need a nearly 2 hour podcast to tell me that a scene that I watched was "funny." I'm glad it makes them laugh, but please, I need more than that to make a podcast worthy of my time. My main criticism is that the hosts present an anti-feminist viewpoint. I'm sure they do this thinking that they are feminists, which is even more irksome. They have spent time tearing down actresses' bodies (which is an insult to the actress, not the costumers). They've referred to main and supporting characters using the terms, "sl--" and "B----." In the 21st century, sl-- -shaming and insults as banal as "B----" set women back decades. In their case, they use "b----" truly as an insult and not as a reclaim. It demonstrates a basic disrespect for women and the forwarding of women's equality. They then proceed to objectify the men on the show. This is supremely frustrating as a listener. It's nice that the hosts interweave listener feedback, but it seems like they don't edit this feedback well. There are four primary commenters who seem to be featured on every podcast. I think this might be because they don't really get much else. I'm really tired of hearing the same listeners' opinions featured over and over. They seem to be given podcast time even if the comment doesn't add value. If the comment adds value then it makes sense. Sometimes it feels like the hosts are simply trying to add time. I really enjoy the 'cups of coffee drank', the internal and external reference features, and music lists. These add a great amount of value to the podcast. However, the hosts are often inaccurate in the references origins. I'm challenged because while I love Gilmore Girls the show, Return to Stars Hollow the podcast leaves a lot to be desired.