April 29, 2026

S2 Ep16: The Mennonite Girl

In tonight’s dead letter, a peaceful retreat at a friend's historic property in the country yields a brush with something that defies explanation. The old homes in these rural communities are steeped in generations of human memory, and sometimes, those overlaid paths from the past seem to bleed right through the present day. We unpack an incredibly vivid, solid sighting that leaves us questioning the true nature of time, space, and the boundaries of our own backyards.REFERENCE LINKSThe Finger Lakes RegionHistory of the Amish and Mennonite SchismSpolia in ArchitectureBelhurst Castle and the Lady in WhiteAl Jaffee and the Mad Magazine Fold-InWe're looking for more stories! Send your Dead Letter to deadletteroffice@astonishinglegends.com!

Also available on Apple Podcasts ↗